Suggestions
Explore the featured selections!
About
Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner
Welcome to Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner, an iconic culinary gem nestled in the heart of Midtown Manhattan at 548 3rd Avenue. This beloved establishment has become a staple for both locals and tourists seeking an authentic New York deli experience. With a historic charm that reflects the essence of classic Jewish delis, Sarge's transports you to a time when hearty meals and flavorful dishes were the norms.
As you step inside, the atmosphere is warm and inviting, filled with the chatter of satisfied customers delighting in generous portions of some of the best comfort food New York has to offer. The restaurant boasts a menu rich in tradition, featuring standout dishes like the legendary pastrami on rye. Customers rave about this signature sandwich, which is lovingly crafted from juicy, tender, and thinly sliced pastrami piled high on the softest rye bread. It's no surprise that you're likely to hear praises from diners claiming it to be the best they’ve ever had.
Sarge’s truly excels at providing comfort, too. Their Matzah ball soup is the perfect antidote for a chilly day, with its flavorful broth and fluffy matzah balls that many have hailed as "out of control." Each bowl is a cozy reminder of home, making the deli a perfect refuge when you crave something warm and satisfying.
For those looking to indulge further, the three-meat platter showcases a delightful array of flavors that promise to leave your taste buds dancing. And don’t forget the pickles—crisp, tangy, and brimming with crunch, they’re a must-have accompaniment to any meal.
As you savor your meal, take a moment to appreciate the attentive service that complements the culinary offerings. It’s evident that Sarge’s Delicatessen & Diner is more than just a restaurant; it’s a cherished institution where every detail is crafted with care and passion. From the extensive menu to the heartwarming ambiance, a visit here feels like a rite of passage in the rich tapestry of New York’s dining scene.
Whether you’re a long-time fan or a first-time visitor, Sarge’s promises a fulfilling experience that honors the legacy of classic deli fare. So, grab a seat and prepare to dive into a feast that combines nostalgia with undeniable deliciousness—you won't leave disappointed!
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ Just a great old school Jewish deli in Midtown serving delicious food. They put out a solid pastrami on rye. It is thinly sliced and I prefer a bit thicker cut. But they do pack it high and it’s juicy and full of flavor so not complaining too much. They also do a great Matzah ball soup, which was perfect for a cold day. ”
“ I’ve been to here several times over the years, and it never disappoints. If you’re looking for that classic New York deli vibe, this is the place to go. The portions are very large and food is consistently amazing. Sarge’s is a must-visit spot for an authentic NYC deli experience. ”
“ Went here for the first time a few weeks back. Just forgot to write a review. The best jewish deli ever. Been to katz, 4th street here in philly. The pastrami was so tasty and cut thinner which i loved. Matzo ball soup was out control. My wife also got a 3 meat platter. Good pickles that arrive on the table. Higly highly recommend. ”
“ I found out about this place from a NYC YouTuber I follow Jon Barr @Here.Be.Barr. It definitely doesn't disappoint. It was so good and I could only eat half of The Hudson "Born December 12th, 2018". It's a corned beef and pastrami Reuben sandwich. ”
“ Chose sarge's over the other establishments on combination of distance and reviews. So I don't have much to weigh it against. It was the best pastrami I've ever had, tender, juicy thin cut slices piled high upon the softest must supple rye bread I've ever had. The cream slaw was as good as any PA Dutch establishment you can find. I devoured it. The Pickles were outstanding, crisp with plenty of crunch and loaded with salty sour flavor. The strawberry cheesecake i took back to the hotel was some 3-4" thick, velvety smooth, but not too rich. Dr. Browns root beer was better than other gourmet style sodas I've had like Hanks. The atmosphere was great. The waitress was great. Leaving this place felt like a NYC achievement, a handshake of understanding there are no doubts about this institution of classic New York cuisine. ”
“ I was so eager to try the pastrami sandwich from one of the recommended delis. Fortunately sarges is well located, the interior decor has an old fashioned charm. The portions were huge, I couldn't finish my soup as I knew my sandwich was on its way. The beef was so tender and went really well with the pickle. The soup was very clean tasting and I imagined great on a cold day but the star was the pastrami. ”
“ It was so nice and I loved it food was great best ever fries. I recommend to come here really good for family's and dates. Overall it is amazing! I loved my waitress she was so kind and friendly. From FLORENCE age 9 UK ”
“ I’ve been to New York many times and this is my favorite deli by far. Unbelievable freshness. You must get this pastrami, no matter what. Also, the cheesecake is super legit as well. Forget every other deli. They have nothing on this one. Also, as a bonus, they have awesome skin on snapping type of hotdogs. Those are legit too. ”